Every now and then, you stumble across a bourbon bargain that’s simply too good to pass up. That happened recently when I walked into Shores Liquor and discovered O.K.I. Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon selling for $20. This is a bottle that normally retails for around $52, so I wasn’t about to leave it sitting on the shelf.
I’ve mentioned this O.K.I. bargain before, but I started wondering just how good a deal I’d actually gotten. Sure, I’d saved $32 on a bottle of bourbon, but a discount doesn’t necessarily make something a bargain. If the bourbon isn’t any good, even $20 might be too much to spend.
So I decided to put O.K.I. to the test against four other bottled-in-bond bourbons, ranging from $20 to $48. And because the O.K.I. normally sells for $52, I could compare it against bourbons in both its regular price range and the bargain category where I’d purchased it.
The contenders were Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond ($20), Wolcott Bottled-in-Bond ($35), New Riff Bottled-in-Bond ($45), Redemption 6-Year Bottled-in-Bond ($48) and O.K.I. Bottled-in-Bond ($52 retail, but $20 out of my pocket).
All five bourbons are bottled-in-bond, which means they’re all 100 proof. That eliminated proof as a variable, allowing me to concentrate on the aromas, flavors, mouthfeel and finish of each bourbon. I poured all five into Glencairn glasses, randomized their order and tasted them blind. No labels, no price tags and no preconceived ideas about which bottle should win.
And the results were interesting, to say the least.
The Blind Tasting
Glencairn A — 80.24
The first pour was a light copper color, with a nose featuring light oak, caramel, nutmeg and apples. The palate reflected those aromas nicely, offering cinnamon-caramel apples, brown sugar and a backing of mild oak. The mouthfeel was on the thin side — not bad, but nothing special — and the finish was modest, with brown sugar and cinnamon lingering.
Overall, it was a pleasant bourbon and a good start to the blind, but I suspected it would finish somewhere around the middle of the pack. As it turned out, I was a little too optimistic.
Glencairn B — 79.53
This one was a very light copper color, perhaps bordering on deep amber. Oak dominated the nose, accompanied by dusty peanut shells and faint wafts of caramel and vanilla. The palate started with those dusty peanuts and caramel, with cinnamon and vanilla playing supporting roles.
It was decent, but a bit one-note. Surprisingly, the mouthfeel was nicely viscous, and the finish was satisfying, delivering buttered toffee, cinnamon and vanilla. Unfortunately, the pleasant texture and finish weren’t quite enough to overcome the relatively limited flavor profile.
Glencairn C — 82.41
Another light copper bourbon, this one opened with sweet tree fruit, light brown sugar, vanilla and caramel on the nose. The palate was particularly appealing, with creamy peanut butter, brown sugar, cinnamon and mild oak.
The mouthfeel was the best of the tasting to that point — creamy and viscous — and the finish delivered brown sugar, toffee and baking spice. Everything worked together nicely, making this the most complete bourbon I’d encountered so far.
Glencairn D — 82.19
This bourbon was very light copper in color, with a somewhat restrained nose featuring apples, light brown sugar, caramel and vanilla. But the palate was considerably more expressive, starting sweet and a bit spicy with honey, brown sugar, cinnamon, toasted nuts, toffee and vanilla.
The mouthfeel was nicely creamy, with nuts and creamy caramel driving the train. This was another very satisfying bourbon, and it came remarkably close to taking the top spot.
Glencairn E — 80.72
The final pour was dark amber, with a richer nose than the color had led me to expect. Caramel, modest oak, cherries, nutmeg and vanilla made for a very inviting combination.
The palate was buttery, bringing toffee, cinnamon, vanilla, oak and tart cherries. Unfortunately, the mouthfeel was relatively modest, and the finish followed suit, with toffee, cherries and vanilla. I enjoyed the flavors, particularly the cherry notes, but the overall experience didn’t quite match the two highest-scoring bourbons.
And the Winners Are …
When I revealed the bottles, I got a surprise. Actually, I got several.
| Finish | Bourbon | Blind Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond | 82.41 |
| 2 | Redemption 6-Year Bottled-in-Bond | 82.19 |
| 3 | O.K.I. Bottled-in-Bond | 80.72 |
| 4 | New Riff Bottled-in-Bond | 80.24 |
| 5 | Wolcott Bottled-in-Bond | 79.53 |
That’s right. The least expensive bourbon in the entire competition, Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond, finished first.
And it didn’t win because I was being generous to a budget bourbon. I didn’t know what I was drinking. Evan Williams simply delivered the most satisfying combination of flavors, mouthfeel and finish of the five bottles in this particular tasting.
Redemption came remarkably close, finishing just 0.22 points behind. Its combination of honey, brown sugar, toasted nuts and creamy caramel made it an excellent pour. At $48, however, it’s considerably more expensive than the Evan Williams.
O.K.I. finished third, which wasn’t a bad showing. I especially enjoyed its caramel, tart cherry and nutmeg notes. But its relatively modest mouthfeel and finish kept it from competing with the top two bottles. New Riff was pleasant but somewhat underwhelming at $45, while Wolcott finished last despite having a surprisingly nice texture and finish.
Of course, the Bourbon Cheapskate isn’t just about which bourbon tastes best. It’s about getting the most enjoyment for the money.
And that’s where things get really interesting.
The Cheapskate Rankings
My Cheapskate scale factors the bourbon’s tasting score against its price, rewarding bottles that deliver a better drinking experience without demanding a premium price.
Here are the results using what I actually paid for each bottle.
| Finish | Bourbon | Price | Cheapskate Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Evan Williams BiB | $20 | 97.41 |
| 2 | O.K.I. BiB | $20 | 95.72 |
| 3 | Redemption 6-Year BiB | $48 | 88.44 |
| 4 | Wolcott BiB | $35 | 88.10 |
| 5 | New Riff BiB | $45 | 86.90 |
Evan Williams didn’t just win the blind tasting. It absolutely dominated the Cheapskate rankings, finishing with a 97.41. That’s an extraordinary showing for a $20 bourbon, especially considering it also earned the highest tasting score.
But look at O.K.I.
At the $20 Shores price, O.K.I. earned a 95.72 on the Cheapskate scale, finishing comfortably in second place. Suddenly, the bourbon that finished third in the blind tasting became one of the best values of the competition.
Here’s the catch. If I’d paid the regular $52 retail price for O.K.I., its Cheapskate score would have been just 86.49, dropping it all the way to last place in the value rankings.
That’s a 9.23-point difference without changing a single thing about the bourbon itself.
Same whiskey. Same flavors. Same 80.72 tasting score. But a completely different value proposition depending on what I paid for the bottle.
That illustrates something I’ve been saying for a long time. A good bourbon isn’t necessarily a good value, and an expensive bourbon isn’t necessarily better than an inexpensive one. Price and quality don’t always travel together.
The $20 Knockout
I went into this tasting expecting to find out whether the O.K.I. I’d purchased at Shores was worth its regular $52 price tag. And while I enjoyed it, I don’t think its performance justified that price compared with the other bottles in the competition.
At $20, however, it’s a different story. I’d gladly buy another bottle at that price, especially with those caramel, cherry and nutmeg flavors. Shores gave me a legitimate bargain, and I’m happy I took advantage of it.
But the real revelation was Evan Williams.
Here’s a bourbon that doesn’t require finding a special sale, waiting for a closeout or stumbling across a retailer trying to move inventory. Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond is a readily available, affordable bourbon that you can often find for around $20. And in this particular blind tasting, it beat bottles costing more than twice as much.
Redemption deserves some recognition, too. It finished virtually tied with Evan Williams on the tasting scale and came in third on the Cheapskate scale. If I were judging purely on drinking enjoyment, I’d happily pour either one. But when I factor in the price, it’s difficult to justify spending $48 when a $20 bottle delivers an equally satisfying — and in this case, slightly better — experience.
I don’t consider Wolcott or New Riff bad bourbons, either. They simply didn’t distinguish themselves enough in this tasting to make their higher prices particularly attractive. And that’s the beauty of tasting blind. The labels and price tags can’t influence your expectations when you don’t know which bourbon is in the glass.
So, did I get a bargain on that O.K.I.?
Absolutely. Saving $32 on a bottle I genuinely enjoy is always welcome, and its 95.72 Cheapskate score confirms that the $20 purchase was money well spent.
But sometimes the best bargain isn’t the bottle marked down from $52 to $20. Sometimes it’s the bottle that was $20 all along.
And this time, Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond delivered the knockout punch.
Enjoyed this? Subscribe and get future reflections, bourbon notes, and assorted nonsense delivered straight to your inbox.
Copyright © 2026 Doug DeBolt.