The Top 40 Nobody Asked For

What’s the weirdest (harmless) obsession you’ve ever had?

View all responses

I’ve developed a peculiar habit over the years. Every now and then, I decide that I need to become an expert in something that plenty of other people already know far more about than I ever will. And rather than simply enjoying whatever has captured my interest, I develop a system to measure it, rank it and publish my findings for the benefit of an audience that may or may not actually exist.

I’ve done this with country music, pop music and Christian music. At various points, I maintained my own Top 40 charts for each of them. And I wasn’t simply listening to songs and deciding which ones I liked best. That would have been far too easy. I was collecting data from existing charts and other sources, developing formulas, feeding the information into a matrix and producing rankings that I believed offered a reasonably accurate picture of what was popular.

Basically, I appointed myself the editor of my own little version of Billboard magazine. Without the staff, the advertising revenue or, for that matter, much of an audience.

I did something similar with college football. Not content to follow the polls that everyone else was using, I developed a system to rank every team in college football. Every. Single. Team. And I spent an extraordinary amount of time gathering information, updating the rankings and trying to determine whether my system was producing reasonable results.

Then there was Yacht Rock. Apparently, simply enjoying the smooth sounds of the late 1970s and early 1980s wasn’t sufficient. I needed a rating scale to determine just how much Yacht Rock each song actually contained. I still have that scale saved on my computer, and I might even get around to using it again someday.

Some of those projects were more enjoyable than others. I liked a lot of the country music I was listening to, so maintaining that chart wasn’t particularly unpleasant. The pop chart was another matter entirely. I started it largely because I wanted to understand the music my students were listening to. I figured that knowing something about their musical interests might help me connect with them.

Unfortunately, the more contemporary pop music I listened to, the more I realized how much of it I couldn’t stand. Eventually, I decided that understanding my students’ musical tastes wasn’t worth subjecting myself to hours of music that grated on my nerves. They could have their music. I was perfectly content to leave it to them.

I’ve had a similar experience with contemporary Christian music. There are certainly songs and artists I enjoy, but the Christian music industry seems determined to go overboard with whatever happens to be working at the moment. Listen to a Christian radio station for more than an hour and you may feel as though you’ve heard the same handful of songs several times.

That’s particularly frustrating because I remember the Christian music of the 1980s and 1990s, when we had what I considered a terrific alternative to the popular music of the day. I’d much rather listen to a station playing those classics than spend an afternoon listening to today’s Christian radio.

In fact, a while back, I started compiling year-by-year Christian music charts beginning with 1981, turning them into Spotify playlists. I made it through 1985 before putting the project aside. But that’s one musical obsession I genuinely want to revisit, because those playlists are something I’ll actually listen to. Even if nobody else ever clicks on them, I’ll enjoy the music.

And that’s the distinction I’ve gradually come to recognize.

For years, I was pouring enormous amounts of time into these elaborate ranking systems and publishing the results on my WordPress site. But let’s be realistic. Who goes to somebody’s personal blog looking for a country music Top 40? Or a pop music chart? I got a little traction with the college football rankings, but nowhere near enough to justify the time I was investing in them.

Eventually, I realized that the effort was infinitely greater than the return. And I’m not just talking about page views. Even the personal satisfaction I got from maintaining those systems wasn’t enough to justify all the work. What had started as an interesting challenge had become another obligation, and I already had plenty of those.

So I stopped. I retired the music charts and the comprehensive college football rankings. Yacht Rock went into temporary storage on my computer. And I reclaimed some time for things that actually mattered more to me.

Of course, I still have my bourbon ratings, complete with scores calculated to two decimal places, blind tastings, March Madness rankings and a Cheapskate scale. I still make college football predictions with Scott every week. And every December, I somehow convince myself that compiling Christmas music, movies, television schedules and daily reflections is a perfectly reasonable way to celebrate the season.

Apparently, the obsession with ranking, organizing and analyzing things hasn’t gone anywhere. I’ve just become a little more selective about which projects deserve my attention.

And those Christian music Spotify playlists? I still intend to pick up where I left off in 1985. The difference is that I’m not creating them to impress anyone, attract readers or establish myself as an authority. I’m creating them because I love that music and want to listen to it.

If somebody else enjoys them, that’s wonderful. If nobody does, I’ve still got a collection of music that makes me happy.

I suppose that’s the lesson I’ve learned from all these peculiar obsessions. There’s nothing wrong with spending time on something simply because you enjoy it. But when the effort becomes greater than the enjoyment, maybe it’s time to find something else to do.

Preferably something that doesn’t require another spreadsheet.

Enjoyed this? Subscribe and get future reflections, bourbon notes, and assorted nonsense delivered straight to your inbox.

Copyright © 2026 Doug DeBolt.

 

Unknown's avatar

About Douglas Blaine

Capnpen is a writer who was a newspaper and magazine journalist in a previous life. A college journalism major, he now works as an English teacher, but gets his writing fix by blogging about a variety of topics, including politics, religion, movies and television. When he's not working or blogging, Capnpen spends time with his family, plays a little golf (badly) and loves to learn about virtually anything.
This entry was posted in Daily Prompt, Music, Random and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply