The Final Cut: What Women Want (2000)

Rating: ★★★½ out of ★★★★★

There’s something about a good romantic comedy that makes for an enjoyable evening at home. Daryl and I both love rom-coms, although our favorites aren’t necessarily the same. Mine is Arthur, the 1981 classic starring Dudley Moore. Hers is How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, with Matthew McConaughey and Kate Hudson. We’ve watched both so many times that we practically know what’s coming before it happens. Every now and then, though, we decide to venture into something we haven’t watched together before.

Monday night, that something was What Women Want, the 2000 romantic comedy starring Mel Gibson and Helen Hunt. I’d seen it before, although I can’t remember exactly when. I’m pretty sure it wasn’t in a theater, and I suspect I first rented it from Blockbuster shortly after it became available. I remember liking it back then, but I hadn’t watched it in years. Daryl had never seen it, so we decided to give it a shot.

We both loved it. There’s plenty of romance, a lot of humor, and enough heart to make it an enjoyable way to spend an evening together. We usually laugh at many of the same things, and this movie gave us plenty of opportunities to do just that.

Gibson plays Nick Marshall, a Chicago advertising executive who has apparently spent his entire adult life perfecting the art of being a male chauvinist. He’s arrogant, self-absorbed, and convinced that women exist primarily to appreciate his charm and good looks. When he gets passed over for a promotion in favor of Darcy McGuire (Helen Hunt), he’s predictably outraged. But after a bizarre accident gives him the ability to hear women’s thoughts, Nick suddenly discovers that the opposite sex isn’t nearly as impressed with him as he always assumed.

This was a different kind of role for Gibson. He’d demonstrated his comedic abilities before, particularly in action comedies, but playing the lead in a romantic comedy required something different. He went all-in on Nick’s chauvinism, which was probably the only way to make the character work. Nick is so thoroughly convinced of his own irresistible appeal that watching his illusions crumble becomes part of the fun. Gibson mostly pulls it off, giving us a character who’s ridiculous enough to laugh at but charming enough that we don’t completely give up on him.

Helen Hunt was in her prime as a leading lady when this movie was made, and she was an excellent choice for Darcy. The filmmakers dialed up her sex appeal without trying to turn her into something she wasn’t. She’s attractive, intelligent, professional and understandably turned off by Nick’s personality. But as Nick begins using his newfound ability to pick her brain, he manages to present himself as a man who seems almost unrealistically compatible with her.

That’s part of the movie’s charm, but it’s also part of its problem. Darcy begins falling for a version of Nick that doesn’t really exist, at least not yet. Gibson and Hunt have good chemistry, for the most part, but the screenplay sometimes asks us to accept emotional developments that haven’t been completely earned.

The supporting cast adds considerably to the entertainment. Marisa Tomei, also at the height of her appeal as a leading lady, is solid as Lola, a coffee shop worker who becomes involved with Nick. Alan Alda, meanwhile, seems almost like an afterthought as Nick’s boss. His primary function is to reinforce the testosterone-heavy corporate culture in which Nick has thrived.

Two supporting performances particularly stood out to me. Ashley Johnson is terrific as Nick’s understandably aggravated teenage daughter, Alex. Their strained relationship feels believable, and she brings some genuine emotional depth to the story. Judy Greer is also excellent as Erin, an overlooked office worker whose increasingly troubling private thoughts finally get Nick’s attention. She’s practically invisible to the people around her, and Nick begins to realize just how badly she’s been neglected. It’s one of the movie’s more meaningful subplots.

But this is a comedy, and when it wants to be funny, it can be downright hilarious.

One of the best scenes comes when Nick decides to experiment with an assortment of women’s beauty products in his bathroom. Gibson throws himself completely into the absurdity, particularly when he tries waxing his legs. After experiencing the pain, he wonders who in the world would ever do that twice—or even bother doing the other leg. It’s a classic sequence, and Gibson’s willingness to make a complete fool of himself is a big reason it works.

Another favorite comes when Nick joins several women in the office for lunch and begins dispensing relationship advice. Suddenly, this lifelong womanizer is something of an expert on relationships. Of course, much of his expertise comes from being able to hear what women are thinking, but I suspect some of it also comes from recognizing the garbage he’s spent years pulling on them. It’s an amusing transformation, watching a man who never really listened to women become someone they actually want to talk to.

And that brings us to what I think is the most interesting aspect of the movie.

Nick can hear women’s thoughts, but that doesn’t mean he understands their hearts.

It’s remarkable that a man could suddenly know exactly what women are thinking and still have trouble figuring out what to do with that information. Nick initially uses his gift for entirely selfish purposes, manipulating people to get what he wants. He knows what Darcy is thinking, so he can say exactly what she wants to hear. He knows what women find appealing, so he can become the man they think they want. But none of that means he’s actually becoming a better person.

That takes time, and it’s where the movie occasionally struggles.

I think Nick’s transformation happens a little too quickly, especially as the story approaches its conclusion. The romance mostly works, but there isn’t quite enough development to make all of it feel genuine. I like the idea behind the story, and I like most of the way it unfolds. I just wish the filmmakers had taken a little more time to let Nick become the man the movie wants us to believe he’s become.

One of his best moments comes when Darcy is considering inviting him up to her apartment. Nick hears what she’s thinking and realizes he has an opportunity to take advantage of the situation. Instead, he tells her he needs to get home. For perhaps the first time, he’s choosing to do the right thing even though he knows he could get exactly what he wants by doing otherwise.

That’s genuine growth. And eventually, Nick is willing to sacrifice his own professional ambitions to make sure Darcy receives the recognition she deserves. He’s finally learning that understanding someone isn’t simply about knowing what they’re thinking. It’s about caring enough to put their interests ahead of your own.

Unfortunately, the ending arrives a little too conveniently. I wanted to believe completely in Nick’s transformation, and I came close. But the movie needed a little more time and development to get me all the way there.

Still, there’s plenty to love about What Women Want. Gibson and Hunt are entertaining together, the supporting cast is strong, and the comedy delivers some genuinely memorable moments. There’s also a sweetness to the story that keeps it from becoming just another movie about a womanizer getting his comeuppance.

Daryl and I didn’t spend much time discussing the movie afterward. It was late, and we needed to get some sleep. But we’d both enjoyed it, and sometimes that’s enough. Not every movie night requires a philosophical discussion about the meaning of life or the intricacies of relationships.

I’ll give What Women Want 3½ out of five stars. That’s a solid thumbs-up and enough to earn a fresh rating in my book. It’s not a movie I’m likely to revisit in the immediate future, but I’d certainly recommend it to anyone looking for an entertaining romantic comedy.

There are an awful lot of bad rom-coms out there, and I think those of us who love the genre sometimes give them more credit than they deserve. We want to like them so badly that we’re willing to overlook weak writing, unbelievable relationships and humor that isn’t particularly funny. Sometimes we practically have to talk ourselves into enjoying what we’re watching.

It’s refreshing to find one that doesn’t make us work so hard.

What Women Want isn’t perfect, and it doesn’t quite earn all the emotional payoffs it’s reaching for. But it made us laugh, gave us a romance worth rooting for, and reminded us that listening to someone is only the beginning of understanding them.

For a Monday night on the couch together, that’s a pretty good return on our investment.

The Final Cut: ★★★½ — A charming, funny romantic comedy with a clever premise, appealing performances and a little more heart than its leading man initially deserves.

Enjoyed this? Subscribe and get future reflections, bourbon notes, and assorted nonsense delivered straight to your inbox.

Copyright © 2026 Doug DeBolt.

 

 

Unknown's avatar

About Douglas Blaine

Capnpen is a writer who was a newspaper and magazine journalist in a previous life. A college journalism major, he now works as an English teacher, but gets his writing fix by blogging about a variety of topics, including politics, religion, movies and television. When he's not working or blogging, Capnpen spends time with his family, plays a little golf (badly) and loves to learn about virtually anything.
This entry was posted in Movies, The Final Cut and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply