Monthly Archives: April 2011

> After last night’s disappointing Movie Night, very little has changed in our odds to win or for elimination. Of course, based on the way last week went, who really knows who’s going home? It certainly won’t be based on … Continue reading →

> I’ll admit that I’m still more than a little hacked about the way-too-early elimination of Pia Toscano last week. But Pia’s exit aside, I was still hoping for a strong night of “Songs from the Movies” from the Top … Continue reading →

> One week after the unexpected exit of Pia Toscano, the Idols will tackle the theme of “Songs from the Movies” for only the fourth time in the show’s history. This is a theme that could have used a big … Continue reading →

>In our last entry, we left no doubt about how we felt about Pia Toscano’s much-too-early exit from American Idol. It has been rightly ranked as one of the most shocking eliminations in Idol history, and we consider it to … Continue reading →

>On Thursday night’s American Idol elimination show, we entered knowing a few things: Paul, Stefano, Haley and Jacob were in danger of elimination. Casey and Lauren were on the bubble of the Bottom Three, but were certainly safe. Pia, Scotty … Continue reading →

> In the first four eliminations of American Idol 10, we’ve seen more than half of the ladies exit stage left. Each of them had their quirks that seemed to rub the viewing public’s collective nerves. First came Ashthon Jones … Continue reading →

> As we head into this week’s performance show centered around the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, not much has changed. The leaders who have led all season are still leading. The stragglers who have been struggling as of … Continue reading →

> This week, Idol revisits a theme that it has only touched once before — the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, which was the inspiration for Season 7’s Final Four. In that season, each Idol sang two songs supposedly … Continue reading →

> This week we correctly picked two of the Bottom Three (Naima and Paul), which happened to also be the two we thought would be tabbed for elimination. While the pick of Naima seemed to be an easy conclusion, the … Continue reading →